Saturday, May 9, 2026

Medicine’s missing ingredient: The vanishing art of human connection


A 67-year-old man, a known case of metastatic liver cancer, was brought to my emergency department a few weeks ago with severe abdominal pain and a distressing feeling of tightness in his abdomen since morning.

He had been undergoing treatment at one of the city’s premier cancer hospitals, but that day, he came to us because he had only been prescribed oral medications for his unbearable pain and was not being admitted there — perhaps because there were simply no beds available in such an overcrowded hospital.

At first glance, I assumed the family might not be financially capable of affording treatment at a corporate hospital. But assumptions don’t heal people. So I spoke to him gently, examined him carefully, and treated him the same way every patient deserves to be treated — with patience, empathy, dignity, and a simple human touch.

His frail body trembled with pain as I explained the likely possibilities to his family — ascites, spontaneous bacterial peritonitis, maybe even intestinal obstruction — all conditions that would need urgent investigations, IV medications, admission, and further management.

His wife stood silently near the bed clutching the edge of her saree. His son and daughter exchanged helpless glances before finally saying, almost apologetically, that they did not even have enough money for the investigations. Admission was impossible for them.

For a few seconds, the room fell silent.

Abhi filhaal dard ke liye injection dete hain inhe… phir dekhenge aage kya karna hai,” I said softly.

The son slowly opened his wallet and counted the few crumpled notes they had brought with them. After discussing quietly among themselves, they agreed for the injectables.

As the medications were started, I kept walking back to his bedside every few minutes, asking whether the pain was easing, whether he felt a little better, whether he was comfortable.

And then, about half an hour later, something unexpected happened.

The old man suddenly broke down crying.

Not the restrained tears patients often hide. He cried like someone whose suffering had finally found a voice.

Alarmed, I went near him and asked, “Kya hua? Bahut dard ho raha hai kya?”

He looked at me with eyes full of tears and said words I don’t think I will ever forget:

Aaj tak mujhse kisi doctor ne itne achhe se baat nahi ki hai… meri bimari jaankar log jaanwaron jaisa vyavhaar karte hain.

(Till today, no doctor had spoken to him with kindness. People changed the way they treated him the moment they heard about his disease).

For a moment, I could not respond.

I just stood there… completely numb.

His wife started crying. His children lowered their heads, wiping tears silently as they looked at the old, exhausted man who had already endured more pain, humiliation, and helplessness than anyone should have to.

And in that moment, I realised something heartbreaking.

For those few minutes, the relief in his eyes was not because of the painkiller flowing through his veins.

It was because someone had spoken to him like he still mattered.

Like he was still a human being.

Not just a terminal cancer patient.
Not just another file.
Not just another bed number.

Those words, those tears, and that moment still echo in my mind.

Before they left, I instructed my staff to charge them only for the medicines and consumables and not for the IV therapy, bed charges, or other expenses. Hearing that, the family folded their hands with trembling gratitude, tears rolling down their faces.

As they walked out together, I kept thinking about how little they had actually received medically from us that day — just a few injections and some temporary relief.

And yet, perhaps what touched them most was something medicine textbooks never truly teach us:

Kindness.
Time.
Listening.
Humanity.

Over the last few days, I have kept asking myself a painful question:

Are we, as caregivers, slowly losing the most basic part of healing — the ability to make our patients feel seen, heard, and human?

No comments: